Yesterday, in Commissioner of Taxation v Merchant [2026] HCA 39, the High Court of Australia dismissed respective appeals brought by the Commissioner and Gordon Merchant, the Taxpayer.
Mr Merchant is the founder of Billabong. In 2015, The Merchant Family Trust (MFT) sold Billabong shares to Mr Merchant’s self-managed super fund, crystallising a $56.6 million capital loss. A pair of group companies (GSM and Tironui) then forgave $54.4 million owed by Plantic Technologies, another business in the group of companies. Plantic Technologies was later sold for an $85 million capital gain, sheltered by the Billabong loss.
At first instance, the Court held that the sale of the Billabong shares was a share sale scheme with the dominant purpose of obtaining a tax benefit under s177F of the ITAA. Mr Merchant appealed this finding in the High Court, which was dismissed, observing at [159] that “no other meaningful or realistic commercial objective was achieved” by the transaction.
In its separate appeal, the Commissioner contended that the debt forgiveness arrangement was a scheme having substantially the effect of a scheme by way of or in the nature of a dividend stripping under s177E of the ITAA. The Court, by a 4:3 majority, dismissed the appeal and held at [208] that the “Debt Forgiveness Schemes lacked the common characteristics of dividend stripping in previous cases.”
Kristen Deards SC and Nichola Derrington of Banco Chambers appeared for the Commissioner of Tax. Penelope Bristow of Banco Chambers appeared for Mr Merchant.
